Silent racism and intellectual superiority in Peru

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0261-3050(97)00085-5Get rights and content

Abstract

Historically, racism as it is understood in South Africa or in parts of the Southern United States has not existed in Peru. The absence or at least the existence to a lesser degree of this type of tension grants us a superiority over our northern neighbours. In Peru, emancipation of slaves was relatively easy. This is not to say that there do not exist prejudices against Indians, cholos, and blacks, however these prejudices have not been sanctioned by the law and they have, more than a profound racial feeling, an economic, social and cultural character. Colour does not prevent an aborigine, mestizo, or Negroid from occupying high positions if they can accumulate wealth or achieve political success. Notwithstanding these fortunate cases, there is an enormous distance between the pongos [serfs] of a highland hacienda … and those highly cultured and refined Limeños, who routinely travel to Europe. This distance is neither racial, nor based on place of origin, rather it corresponds to what can be termed an historical state of things (Jorge Basadre, 1964: 4686).

References (85)

  • ArguedasJ.M.

    En defensa del folklore peruano

    La Prensa

    (1994)
  • ArguedasJ.M.
  • BantonM.
  • BalibarEtienne

    Existe un neo-racismo?

  • BarkanE.

    The Retreat of Scientific Racism. Changing Concepts of Race in Britain and the United States Between the World Wars

    (1992)
  • BasadreJ.
  • BasadreJ.
  • BelaúndeV.A.
  • BelaúndeV.A.
  • BenedictR.
  • BenthallJ. et al.

    Ethnic Alleys and Avenues

    Anthropology Today

    (1993)
  • BlancoH.
  • BiddisM.

    The origins of european racism

    Race

    (1966)
  • CallawayH.

    Purity and exotica in legitimating the empire: cultural constructions of gender, sexuality and race

  • Castro PozoH.

    Renuevo de peruanidad

    (1934)
  • CossioF.
  • CuetoM.

    La reforma universitaria de 1919. Universidad y estudiantes a comienzos de siglo

  • De la CadenaM.

    Race, ethnicity and the struggle for self-representation: re-indianization in Cuzco, Peru (1919–1991)

  • De la CadenaM.

    The political tensions of representations and misrepresentations: intellectuals and mestizas in Cuzco (1919–1990)

    Journal of Latin American Anthropology

    (1996)
  • Diario El Sol

    (1919)
  • Diario El Sol

    (1921)
  • Diario El Sol

    (1928)
  • Diario El Sol

    (1929)
  • Díaz MartínezA.
  • EncinasJ.A.

    Prologue

  • EscalanteJ.A.

    Nosotros los indios

  • FrankenbergR.
  • GamioM. et al.
  • GarciaU.
  • García SayánD.
  • GilroyP.

    There Ain't No Black in the Union Jack’. The Cultural Politics of Race and Nation

    (1987)
  • GouldS.
  • GoseP.

    The inquisitional construction of race: limpieza de sangre and racial slurs in 17th century Lima

  • HaddoxJ.

    La Influencia de José Vasconcelos en Victor Raúl Haya de la Torre

  • HaleC.

    Political and social ideas in Latin America 1870–1930

  • IEP
  • KapsoliW.
  • KnightA.

    Racism, revolution and indigenismo: Mexico 1910–1940

  • LettsR.
  • MariáteguiJ.C.

    El indio mestizo

  • MariáteguiJ.C.

    Civilización y feudalidad

  • Cited by (69)

    • Collaborative survival and the politics of livability: Towards adaptation otherwise

      2021, World Development
      Citation Excerpt :

      Naming of environmental problems, including “overgrazing” and a “weak” (campesino) land ethic can be found in official correspondence between HNP and UNESCO just a few short years after their respective establishments, in 1975 and 1977. Since the occupation of conservation enclosures upon indigenous (communal) lands in the Cordillera Blanca, traditional ways of life have become criminalized through globalizing governing logics (Cartesian philosophy and positivist reason) for biodiversity and risk management – what has been identified elsewhere as a “green-” or “eco-governmentality” (Goldman, 2004; Yeh, 2005); “silent racism” (de la Cadena, 1998); and a “crisis of reason” within the global reach of Eurocentric culture (Plumwood, 2002). Since early international conservation efforts, campesinos have come under constant surveillance from a transnational governance regime that condemns their very way of life, viewing it as environmentally detrimental, an impediment to modernizing progress in Peru, and calling for its reduction or elimination (UNESCO, 1987).

    • Making “a racket” but does anybody care? A study of environmental justice access and recognition through the political ecology of voice

      2019, Geoforum
      Citation Excerpt :

      Many of these material and immaterial access factors are interlinked. A significant root cause is Peru’s ‘pervasively discriminatory society’ (Bertelsmann Stiftung, 2016, p. 12) and ‘silent racism’ (de la Cadena, 1998), which have left indigenous people with ‘fifth category’ societal status (CBO4R3) and only a limited voice in the Peruvian political system (Thorp and Paredes, 2010, p. 204). Consequently, whilst the state aggressively pursues its neoliberal extractive agenda in Loreto i.e. the SHDV (Gonzalez, 2018b), it is unwilling to improve rural civic services.

    • Law in Conflict: The Judicialization of Mining Disputes in Peru

      2023, Law in Conflict: The Judicialization of Mining Disputes in Peru
    • The small metal music store as a site of everyday decolonial resistance in Latin America and the Caribbean

      2023, Social Movements and Everyday Acts of Resistance: Solidarity in a Changing World
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text